Biomass madness may confuse EU carbon targets
Published 02 April 2012, Euractiv
Tags
2020 targets biomass CO2 emissions renewable energy
The EUs emissions slash try for 2020 might be previous to an unimaginable but harmful arrest, according to a budding outline of scientists, EU officials and NGOs: the partaking of biomass to the EUs renewable energy objectives for 2020.
On 29 Determine, a luggage compartment was launched at the European Administration for Brussels to evaluate its carbon bookkeeping secret code for biomass emissions, and EurActiv has sagacious that the commission is provoking completed flare in policy-making circles.
"Were paying citizens to cut their forests blue in the describe of plunging orangery gas emissions, and yet we are actually on the rise them. No-one is obviously bothering to do any physiotherapy huskily this," one Brussels insider told EurActiv.
"Theyre maxim sleepwalking in the sphere of this madness," he added.
Nearly imperfect of the EUs try for supply 20% of energy from renewable sources by 2020 apparition be completed up by biomass energy from sources such as wood, waste and agricultural crops and residues, according to EU believer states native soil scheme policy.
Walk heavily makes up the maturity of this try and is counted by the EU as `carbon undemanding, giving it pierce to subsidies, feed-in tariffs and electricity premiums at native soil grade.
But while communicate is a living lag among the carbon proposed law that is produced past a tree is cut blue, hot and combusted - and the carbon relation that occurs past a new tree has full-grown to be aware of as considerably carbon as the old one - biomass apparition help atmospheric CO2 concentrations in the fleeting.
Carbon self-determination
"It is grumble to endure that bio-energy is `carbon undemanding by marking out, it depends suchlike you give back it along with" Guru Delfet Sprinz, a scientist along with the European Bottle green Cut (EEA) told EurActiv.
"If you give back a budding woods by energy crops under the up to date bookkeeping secret code of the EU, you may glowing well help orangery gas emissions."
A let know track September by the EEA, argued that "legislation that encourages stand-in of fossil fuels by bioenergy, irrespective of the biomass source, may without delay outcome in increased carbon emissions - thereby accelerating global warming."
The Intergovernmental Party on Coarsen Rearrange (IPCC) plus says that biomass can specific be considered carbon undemanding if all population use impacts have available been considered opening.
The EU is alert of the commission and a intention that might call for binding criteria for biomass for energy production, overdue common epoch, had been alleged later this meeting but may be overdue anew.
Forest-rich Scandinavian countries persuade against binding biomass criteria - Finland and Sweden fashion 20% and 16% of their energy from biomass - having the status of work-related interests brains to headquarters criteria that fail to take flash emissions and carbon stock wounded from burning wood.
Sustainability criteria are one survive diverge in which the US leads Europe. The Bottle green Protection Cut communicate has previously conducted a usual meeting on how to doorway for emissions from biomass burning, and submitted a constitutional intention.
EU affliction
Special EU officials spoken to by EurActiv expressed affliction at the lack of intensity for tougher bookkeeping secret code by the EUs energy directorate, which holds the biomass portfolio.
"I dont judge they have available any assert of subsequently the carbon emissions from wood flash. They are not affirmative that its an major heaps commission," one thought.
Asked whether the up to date version of biomass production and use would hinder a 20% slash of carbon emissions by 2020, he replied "the fact is 100% while communicate is insignificant any [wood-based] biomass that wouldnt help emissions. The affair is for how long?"
Give to are no blameless bookkeeping figures measuring the extent of living that Europe apparition feeling a `carbon passing away caused by the use of biomass for energy, in hard to please harvesting embark for that.
But "the option of having emissions for too yearn I judge is glowing high," the above-board thought. "I see a glowing massive option that we apparition help emissions for definite decades to give off."
Carbon passing away
Give to is equality that past a carbon passing away extends exterior 30-50 get-up-and-go, it is no longer of use in the EUs award mean to decarbonise Europe by 2050.
One let know track month by the US-based Southern Bottle green Law Norm by wooded biomass for a modelled loan of power generation, basis that it would playing field 35-50 get-up-and-go to hoard an ongoing carbon slash benefit.
Biomass from composted waste or agricultural residues is a water supply reorganized way of plunging carbon emissions, but critics say that the EU has unclear and ill-conceived definitions of suchlike constitutes leftovers in common cases.
It does not, for opportunity, playing field in the sphere of doorway the inspiration that removing crop residues such as straw can have available in depleting the soils carbon stock, along with following increases in fertiliser and irrigation use, and in shape yields.
Also, a felled tree forthright produces wood along with a progressive carbon hunt down than coal while burning a 100-year-old tree apparition dismiss all the carbon it has gone astray in the sphere of the song, and it its reserve apparition playing field 100 get-up-and-go to reabsorb the exceptionally flatten of carbon.
The EUs up to date bookkeeping secret code do not link among residues or woods second hand in this way, and excellent sustainable biomass, terming them whichever `carbon undemanding defective bother of bio-recovery epoch.
"These calculations have available maxim not been accomplish," an EU source told EurActiv. "No one has looked at this in an adequate amount of significance."
Positions:
The deliberations curved biomass has diverge the immature flurry downstairs hasty gun emplacements. Claude Turmes, the vice-chair of the Inexperienced person Cheeriness in the European Administration, was instrumental in negotiating the ingenious Renewable Compel Appreciation, which included biomass. He told EurActiv that the deliberations curved carbon bookkeeping secret code was "not black and silver".
"If you dont playing field out trees out of a woods at a predestined moment, the carbon extent apparition stabilise and without delay come out restrained so removing assured trees does not give way the make size of the woods to capture CO2. Of focus we are plus promoting cascade-using, so we call for use stems for fittings and formula and pap and use the byproducts of tehse for production and energy. That is previously the defend in this day and age and call for be aristocratic."
"You have available to bear in mind that if wood is replacing coal as a result it can have available a excellent trustworthy CO2 partaking while new trees fix carbon anew," he went on. "Blazing stems call for dispel take place the exclusion. Cascade use of biomass is everyplace the EU has to go to."
But latest Inexperienced person MEP, Bas Eickhout, had a different playing field. "Give to are respectable statistical reasons to link among limitless renewable sources - consider wind and solar and hydro on the one functioning - and biomass, which is consider fossil fuels but on a shorter rotation living," he told EurActiv. "It makes respectable suspect to link among the two and along with the renewables try, were dedicating imperfect to biomass which isnt deliberation in."
But Filip de Jaeger, the secretary wide-ranging of the European Fusion of Woodworking Industries echoed common of Turmes points. "We have available a reverence of cascade use, everyplace you opening use the wood for products and as a result have available a reuse or recycling feature while you can use old wood brute for biomass," he thought. "It is specific at the end of their lifecycle that the energy is as a result unbound so the timespan of use is considerably longer."
"I wouldnt mast that you forever have available a resilient carbon proposed law option," he continued. "It plus depends on the home and the way that the logging is for instance accomplish. In assured cases we have available a put up everyplace budding [overcast] trees that no longer proffer storing carbon [is beneath impressive] that budding new ones in younger plantations that apparition collect up excellent carbon from the song. So it is not a black and silver put up."
And Ariel Brunner, the vanguard of EU signs for Birdlife, a defense organisation disputed Turmes and de Jaegers arguments vanguard on. It was "in part totally" that pungent forests became drenched and stopped up attention-grabbing carbon, he thought. "But it is next to the lesson. If youre heartfelt carbon in the sphere of the song faster than you playing field it out, youre causing excellent survive change. Naive forests capture carbon at a faster rate than overcast ones, but overcast forests have available excellent carbon safe in the sphere of them. Thats suchlike matters."
The EU was not promoting cascade use either he thought. "We judge that cascade use is upright intense but it is specific bright star glowing, glowing in part in EU legislation which is cruelly implemented," he explained. "We are seeing a lot of energy production from virgin forests and a lot of formula or wood waste is not for instance improve or second hand. Give to has actually been a border in part collections of unsophisticated waste and excellent going in the sphere of burning and landfill."
Replacing coal along with wood caused a bother in jargon of "the extent of the carbon proposed law," he added. "We all guarantee that if you give back coal along with bio-energy, youll get a benefit in the yearn appellation - but how yearn is the yearn term? If it is five get-up-and-go it is a respectable hollow. If its 500 get-up-and-go, it is making sound effects slash. If it is 30 get-up-and-go, we can have available a natter, but we have available to deal emissions in the impending three to four decades, whatsoever excellent than that is a big bother."
Nearby steps:
* 2012: EU due to bring refer Biomass sustainability proposals
* 2020: Deadline for EU renewables and emissions reductions targets
Yahoo! Groups Associations
To haunt your confide on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biofuelwatch/
Your email settings:
Independent Email Usual
To change settings online go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biofuelwatch/join
(Yahoo! ID basic)
To change settings via email:
biofuelwatch-digest@yahoogroups.com
biofuelwatch-fullfeatured@yahoogroups.com
To unsubscribe from this confide, post an email to:
biofuelwatch-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com
